84e40772ac96d2c6…

Preprint
ID: 5e15f685afc3ff001967352f2,694 bytesFirst seen Jun 24, 20261 collection

Fields

NameValue
abstractWhile political theory occasionally resembles a protracted discussion about violence, the same cannot be said for atrocity. Where something recognizable as atrocity does crop up in canonical texts, it tends to be characterized as a fundamentally extra-political phenomenon. The canon promotes a tautology: atrocity is extra-political and properly political violence is not atrocious. To begin my discussion of atrocity, I first consider the figure of the tyrant and tyrannical violence in Western political thought as a possible proxy issue for early thinking about transgressive violence. Of the many disquisitions on tyranny, Seneca’s distinction between ordinary cruelty and what he calls “bestial savagery” establishes the basis for a theory of atrocity, but it does not go far enough. I then survey canonical discussions of transgressive violence up to the present, emphasizing the recurring theme of non-instrumentality. Finally, I present a tentative formulation of atrocity that underscores its political nature.
abstractViews868
approvedDate2020-01-08T19:31:53.245Z
assetFileNameThe Bull of Phalaris - Reduced.pdf
assetFileSizeBytes235595
assetMimeTypeapplication/pdf
assetUrlhttps://www.cambridge.org/engage/api-gateway/coe/assets/orp/resource/item/5e15f685afc3ff001967352f/original/the-bull-of-phalaris-atrocity-in-the-canon.pdf
authorIds["orcid:0000-0001-5080-5112"]
categoryIds["5ce663395846762193c9c426"]
citations0
commentsCount0
communityIdAPSA
competingInterestsDeclarationnull
contentDownloads982
contentTypeWorking Paper
contentTypeId5ce663395846762193c9c430
doi10.33774/apsa-2020-xkvxd
doiUrlhttps://doi.org/10.33774/apsa-2020-xkvxd
engageUrlhttps://www.cambridge.org/engage/coe/article-details/5e15f685afc3ff001967352f
eventIdnull
funders[]
gainedEthicsApprovalnull
hasCompetingInterestsnull
isLatestVersiontrue
keywords["Atrocity","Violence","Genocide","Cruelty","Phalaris","Torture","Sadism","Evil","Seneca","Aristotle","More","Montaigne","Political Theory","Trangressive Violence"]
licenseId5cc9d9bf7d4e0000ac04ef27
publishedDate2020-01-08T19:31:53.257Z
statusPUBLISHED
statusDate2020-01-08T19:31:53.257Z
subjectId5e68cb1bd1f19d49ce3ac752
submittedDate2020-01-08T15:55:44.479Z
supplementaryFiles[]
thumbnailUrlhttps://www.cambridge.org/engage/api-gateway/coe/assets/orp/resource/item/5e15f685afc3ff001967352f/mediumThumb/the-bull-of-phalaris-atrocity-in-the-canon.jpg
titleThe Bull of Phalaris: Atrocity in the Canon
version1
vornull
webLinks[]

Canonical JSON

{
  "id": "5e15f685afc3ff001967352f",
  "type": "Preprint",
  "data": {
    "abstract": "While political theory occasionally resembles a protracted discussion about violence, the same cannot be said for atrocity. Where something recognizable as atrocity does crop up in canonical texts, it tends to be characterized as a fundamentally extra-political phenomenon. The canon promotes a tautology: atrocity is extra-political and properly political violence is not atrocious. To begin my discussion of atrocity, I first consider the figure of the tyrant and tyrannical violence in Western political thought as a possible proxy issue for early thinking about transgressive violence. Of the many disquisitions on tyranny, Seneca’s distinction between ordinary cruelty and what he calls “bestial savagery” establishes the basis for a theory of atrocity, but it does not go far enough. I then survey canonical discussions of transgressive violence up to the present, emphasizing the recurring theme of non-instrumentality. Finally, I present a tentative formulation of atrocity that underscores its political nature.",
    "abstractViews": 868,
    "approvedDate": "2020-01-08T19:31:53.245Z",
    "assetFileName": "The Bull of Phalaris - Reduced.pdf",
    "assetFileSizeBytes": 235595,
    "assetMimeType": "application/pdf",
    "assetUrl": "https://www.cambridge.org/engage/api-gateway/coe/assets/orp/resource/item/5e15f685afc3ff001967352f/original/the-bull-of-phalaris-atrocity-in-the-canon.pdf",
    "authorIds": [
      "orcid:0000-0001-5080-5112"
    ],
    "categoryIds": [
      "5ce663395846762193c9c426"
    ],
    "citations": 0,
    "commentsCount": 0,
    "communityId": "APSA",
    "competingInterestsDeclaration": null,
    "contentDownloads": 982,
    "contentType": "Working Paper",
    "contentTypeId": "5ce663395846762193c9c430",
    "doi": "10.33774/apsa-2020-xkvxd",
    "doiUrl": "https://doi.org/10.33774/apsa-2020-xkvxd",
    "engageUrl": "https://www.cambridge.org/engage/coe/article-details/5e15f685afc3ff001967352f",
    "eventId": null,
    "funders": [],
    "gainedEthicsApproval": null,
    "hasCompetingInterests": null,
    "isLatestVersion": true,
    "keywords": [
      "Atrocity",
      "Violence",
      "Genocide",
      "Cruelty",
      "Phalaris",
      "Torture",
      "Sadism",
      "Evil",
      "Seneca",
      "Aristotle",
      "More",
      "Montaigne",
      "Political Theory",
      "Trangressive Violence"
    ],
    "licenseId": "5cc9d9bf7d4e0000ac04ef27",
    "publishedDate": "2020-01-08T19:31:53.257Z",
    "status": "PUBLISHED",
    "statusDate": "2020-01-08T19:31:53.257Z",
    "subjectId": "5e68cb1bd1f19d49ce3ac752",
    "submittedDate": "2020-01-08T15:55:44.479Z",
    "supplementaryFiles": [],
    "thumbnailUrl": "https://www.cambridge.org/engage/api-gateway/coe/assets/orp/resource/item/5e15f685afc3ff001967352f/mediumThumb/the-bull-of-phalaris-atrocity-in-the-canon.jpg",
    "title": "The Bull of Phalaris: Atrocity in the Canon",
    "version": "1",
    "vor": null,
    "webLinks": []
  }
}

Appears in 1 collection

cambridge-up/open-engage1 version · Jun 24, 2026

Full hash:84e40772ac96d2c6ba2382e33818fd2c57d28c9afdf2bf8e6aa6db9773b4cae7